[Lofarpwg] [DKIM: Failed] Re: Fwd: AA/2019/36627: referee report [LBA census]

[Michael Kramer]

Excellent! Well done, Anya!

Cheers, Michael


> On 13 Oct 2019, at 22:20, Anna Bilous <hanna.bilous at gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> Dear all,
> 
> please find below the referee report for the LBA census.
> 
> Cheers,
> Anya
> 
> ---------- Forwarded message ---------
> From: <aanda.paris at obspm.fr>
> Date: Sat, Oct 5, 2019 at 4:02 PM
> Subject: AA/2019/36627: referee report
> To: <hanna.bilous at gmail.com>
> 
> 
> 05/10/2019
> 
> Dr Anna Bilous
> 
> hanna.bilous at gmail.com
> Our Ref. : AA/2019/36627
> 
> Dear Dr Bilous,
> 
> The manuscript entitled :
> 
> "A LOFAR census of non-recycled pulsars: extending below 80 MHz"
> 
> was submitted to a referee, Joanna Rankin (who waives anonymity), who
> recommends publication following very minor revision (see enclosed
> report).
> 
> Please make the requested changes and send us the revised version (two
> pdf files: one in referee format and the other in printer format) at
> your earliest convenience. Instructions for resubmitting can be found
> at address https://mms-aanda.obspm.fr/is/aa/resubmit_a_paper.php. Your
> author ID number is 25070.
> 
> Also make sure that the figure and table captions are formatted in
> accordance with the A&A instructions (see
> http://www.aanda.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=136&Itemid=200&lang=en_GB.utf8%2C+en_GB.UT#paper_organisation
> and the current A&A macro for examples).
> 
> - In your cover letter, please indicate precisely all the changes made
> in the revised version,
> - Mark all the changes clearly (using boldface) in your manuscript.
> 
> The final acceptance letter will give you the exact acceptance date as
> well as instructions for sending your paper to the publisher. Please
> do not send your manuscript to the publisher before receiving the
> notice of acceptance.
> 
> With best regards,
> 
> steve
> 
> Steven N. Shore
> A&A Editor
> -------------------
> Referee report
> 
> Overall:  this is a complex and well crafted project, and the results
> are very well and capably described.  I recommend publication with
> only slight revisions.
> 
> 
> Small issues:
> —in several places “Similarly to…” should be “Similar to ….”
> —in the third paragraph of §3, Hotan et al is referenced twice in 3
> lines.  Maybe rephrase to eliminate one of them?
> —second line of the first full para on p. 3: fix grammar and spacing
> in “data packets was dropped,resulting”
> —Fig. 3 caption:  I don’t see any blue stars, they seem black to me
> —§3.2, para 1, line 8: “polarizations summed."
> —third to last line on p. 4: “flux density values with the ones”
> —§5, para 3, l. 9: “proposes a clear dependence"
> —Appendix A: is it “scintle” or “scintile”?
> _______________________________________________
> lofarpwg mailing list
> lofarpwg at astron.nl
> http://mailman.astron.nl/listinfo/lofarpwg

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prof. Dr. Michael Kramer
Director - Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie, Bonn, Germany
Professor for Astrophysics - University of Manchester, UK
Professor (Hon-Prof.) - University of Bonn, Germany

Address:   MPI fuer Radioastronomie
                 Auf dem Huegel 69
                 53121 Bonn, Germany

Phone: +49-228-525-278 (direct)
           +49-228-525-299 (secretary)

EMAIL:  mkramer at mpifr-bonn.mpg.de / michael.kramer at manchester.ac.uk
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------